Connect with us

Featured

Virgil Van Dijk’s goal was ruled out by VAR for an offside on Andy Robertson. Robertson ducked out of the way of the ball. Eight minutes later, Man City go up 2-0.

Published

on

Was it correct to disallow Liverpool equaliser?

,

 

Van Dijk goal against Man City ‘should have stoo

 

Liverpool may have been on the end of a 3-0 defeat at Manchester City, but did a pivotal moment dramatically alter the course of the game?

 

The Premier League champions were 1-0 down at the time following Erling Haaland’s opener just before the half-hour mark.

 

However, the Reds thought they had equalised in the 38th minute when captain Virgil van Dijk headed home.

 

The Netherlands centre-back escaped the attentions of Matheus Nunes and met Mohamed Salah’s inswinging corner just outside the six-yard box.

 

Van Dijk planted a powerful header beyond the dive of City goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma and ran off in celebration.

 

However, the assistant referee then decided to raise his flag and a check by the video assistant referee (VAR) determined that Liverpool defender Andy Robertson interfered with play from an offside position and it was disallowed.

 

Robertson had his back to goal just in front of the line, behind Jeremy Doku, and ducked out of the way of Van Dijk’s header.

 

Liverpool manager Arne Slot told Sky Sports it was “obvious and clear that the wrong decision has been made” to disallow the goal.

 

“He didn’t interfere at all with what the goalkeeper could do. Immediately after the game someone showed me the goal that the same referee allowed – City against Wolves last season,” he said.

 

“So it took the linesman 13 seconds to raise his flag to say it was offside. So there was clearly communication, but as I said that [goal] could have influenced the game in a positive way for us.”

 

Van Dijk said that “the officials are deciding the key decisions” and there was “no point discussing this from my point of view”.

 

He added: “It doesn’t matter what I say [about the goal] because anything I say will be in the media and the whole international break will be about my comment on the decision.”

 

So was it the correct call?

 

‘It can’t go on’ – how Liverpool’s tactics helped brilliant Doku run riot

 

Published

 

55 minutes ago

 

Man City make ominous statement on chastening night for Liverpool

 

Published

 

3 hours ago

 

What information do we collect from this quiz?

 

What does the law say?

 

Image source,Getty Images

 

Image caption,

 

Virgil van Dijk was unhappy with the decision to disallow the goal

 

Offside is covered by law 11 of the IFAB Laws of the Game 2025-26., external

 

The graphic below clarifies the law and the Premier League’s match centre on X made specific reference to the incident.

 

“The referee’s call of offside and no goal to Liverpool was checked and confirmed by VAR – with Robertson in an offside position and deemed to be making an obvious action directly in front of the goalkeeper,” it said.

 

Image source,Premier League

 

‘The wrong decision’ – what the pundits said

 

Image source,Getty Images

 

Image caption,

 

Andrew Robertson ducked out of the way of Virgil van Dijk’s header to allow the ball to go into the net

 

The decision to disallow Van Dijk’s goal provoked debate among pundits.

 

Former Liverpool midfielder Danny Murphy said the goal “should stand” because Robertson was “not in Donnarumma’s line of vision”.

 

Ex-Manchester United defender Gary Neville said during Sky Sports’ commentary he was “not sure” if it should have been chalked off because Robertson was “to the left of Donnarumma” and he was “not convinced” the City goalkeeper “is ever getting near that”.

 

Former Aston Villa forward Dion Dublin said “Robertson is in an offside position” but crucially was “not in his [Donnarumma’s] eyeline”.

 

“I have seen it two or three times and if anyone could be in his eyeline it would be Jeremy Doku,” Dublin added.

 

Ex-Manchester United striker Wayne Rooney agreed that it should have stood and said: “I don’t think Andy Robertson delayed Donnarumma diving. The City keeper can see the ball the whole way so I think that was the wrong decision.”

 

 

03:21

 

Media caption,

 

Liverpool ‘completely dominated’ by Manchester City in first half, says Slot

 

‘Not about the line of vision’ – analysis

 

ByDale Johnson

 

Football issues correspondent

 

Subjective offside decisions, those where the player does not touch the ball, are always controversial.

 

They require interpretation about impact from the officials, and that is often not straightforward.

 

And Chris Kavanagh, who was the referee for Sunday’s game, knows all about them.

 

As Virgil van Dijk’s header made its way towards goal, Andrew Robertson ducked to allow the ball to go into the net. The Scotland international was stood offside, and the assistant raised his flag for offside.

 

This decision was not about line of vision, but “an obvious action which clearly impacts on the ability of an opponent to play the ball”.

 

The offside law does not require a referee to think Manchester City goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma would definitely save it, only that his ability to do so has been affected. It is the ducking motion which is absolutely crucial because it could put doubt into the goalkeeper’s mind about a potential touch.

 

If Donnarumma had not been stood close to Robertson, or if the Scotland international was not in the six-yard area, the case for offside would have been weak.

 

But there must be an argument that Donnarumma had been impacted. For that reason, as the on-field team gave offside, it was not likely to be overturned through a VAR review.

 

It is a borderline call, but still supportable as an on-field decision.

 

However, officials are advised it’s usually best to leave complicated subjective offside decisions to the VAR, and if that had happened Liverpool would likely have had an equaliser.

 

A good comparison is a disallowed Everton goal against Manchester United in March 2020. Dominic Calvert-Lewin’s shot was deflected towards goal, and an offside Gylfi Sigurdsson, who was sat inside the six-yard box, withdrew his legs to allow the ball through. The referee? Chris Kavanagh.

 

We can compare it to a goal which was given through VAR last season. John Stones’ late winner for Manchester City at Wolves was chalked off on the field for Bernardo Silva being in the line of vision of goalkeeper Jose Sa.

 

But while he was close to Sa he wasn’t in front of him and, unlike Robertson, he did not duck out of the path of the ball. The referee? Chris Kavanagh.

 

We have seen a couple of similar situations this season – a Manchester United goal at Nottingham Forest, and one for Leeds against Bournemouth – where an offside player has made a small movement away from the ball.

 

In those cases it was felt that movement and the positions of the players (they were not inside the six-yard box) was not enough to affect the goalkeeper.

 

 

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Featured

RUMORS: Real Madrid manager Xabi Alonso is reportedly keen to reunite with Florian Wirtz despite his struggles at Liverpool. With Liverpool still interested in Rodrygo, a swap deal between the two players is reportedly being considered

Published

on

Real Madrid Willing To Sacrifice Star Player In Swap Deal With Liverpool

 

Xabi Alonso would be ‘delighted’ to have him at Madrid.

 

Real Madrid are open to the idea of a swap deal involving Rodrygo, according to reports in Spain, with Xabi Alonso willing to ‘facilitate’ a move for one of Liverpool’s summer signings.

 

Since joining the club in a £39 million move from Santos, Rodrygo has made over 250 appearances for Los Blancos across a trophy-laden six-year spell.

 

He impressed under Carlo Ancelotti, winning three La Liga titles and the Champions League twice, but the Brazil international has played a bit-part role of late, especially under new manager Xabi Alonso.

 

As a result, Rodrygo was heavily linked with a summer move. Arsenal and Chelsea were both rumoured to be interested alongside recently-crowned Premier League champions Liverpool

 

Spanish publication AS claimed Liverpool expressed an interest and were keeping tabs on his delicate situation at Madrid, but they eventually focused on other targets, including Florian Wirtz.

 

Rodrygo has struggled for starts under Xabi Alonso. Image credit: Getty

 

Wirtz, who eventually joined Liverpool for £116 million, had been tracked by Madrid for several months.

 

However, the Spanish club were unwilling to meet the demands made by Bayer Leverkusen and proceeded to withdraw from the bidding process, according to Spanish publication Defensa Central.

 

RUMORS: Real Madrid manager Xabi Alonso is reportedly keen to reunite with Florian Wirtz despite his struggles at Liverpool. With Liverpool still interested in Rodrygo, a swap deal between the two players is reportedly being considered!🚨🔴⚪️??

 

#RealMadrid #Liverpool #Transfers

The report also claims Wirtz ‘wouldn’t have hesitated’ to join Los Blancos if they had made a suitable offer.

 

In fact, as the German struggles to adapt to life in the Premier League, Madrid would be willing to include Rodrygo in an audacious swap deal for Wirtz.

 

“Xabi Alonso would be delighted to have him,” the report says. “For now, Real Madrid are following him very closely, aware that he could become a very interesting option to strengthen their midfield in the future.”

 

It adds: “But in the short term, it seems like a virtually impossible move, because Liverpool won’t want to sell him so soon, however interested they may be in Rodrygo.”

 

What has Rodrygo said about Liverpool?

 

Before his move to Madrid, the Brazilian forward came close to signing for Liverpool for just £2.5 million.

 

 

“We didn’t close the deal (with Liverpool) because I didn’t want to,” Rodrygo said in 2024. “I wanted to stay at Santos even though the offer was very good… finally, I was able to fulfil my dream of playing for Santos.”

 

“But it’s true, I almost went to Liverpool in 2017.”

 

 

Rodrygo came up against Liverpool this month. Image credit: Getty

 

Despite turning Liverpool down, he has expressed his admiration for the club and its fans.

 

Advert

 

Speaking ahead of a Champions League clash at Anfield in 2023, he said: “The game there is going to be very difficult, we already know this. Playing against Liverpool is always difficult whether with or without fans, but at Anfield even more.”

 

Continue Reading

Featured

Arsenal injury news: Latest on six stars as Mikel Arteta ‘hoping’ for two Tottenham returns

Published

on

 

Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta is reportedly hoping to have two of his stricken stars back in action for the North London derby with Tottenham Hotspur on November 23.

 

The Gunners are expected to receive a plethora of injury boosts over the international break and have already welcomed the news that Gabriel Jesus has returned to team training after an ACL tear.

 

The Brazil international has been sidelined for 10 months after rupturing his cruciate ligament in January’s FA Cup loss to Manchester United, but he is now on course to return before the end of the calendar year.

 

However, Jesus is still expected to be the last cab off the rank in terms of Arsenal’s injured stars, a list that also includes Martin Odegaard, Viktor Gyokeres, Noni Madueke, Kai Havertz and Gabriel Martinelli.

 

None of the quintet is expected to be sidelined for much longer after the international window, though, and according to The Mirror, two are bidding to return in time for Tottenham straight after the hiatus.

 

Arsenal to welcome two injured stars back for Tottenham clash?

 

 

The report states that attacking duo Gyokeres and Madueke are both pushing to return for the North London derby as they step up their recoveries from respective hamstring and knee complaints.

 

Gyokeres suffered a muscular blow during Arsenal’s 2-0 win over Burnley two Saturdays ago, although reports at the time stated that the Sweden international had avoided a serious issue, and he is expected to be back in full training imminently.

 

Meanwhile, Madueke has been missing since hurting his knee in September’s 1-1 draw with Manchester City – the winger was originally said to have faced up to eight weeks in the treatment room.

 

Without Gyokeres, Havertz or Jesus up front, Arteta was forced to shoe-horn Mikel Merino into a central striking role once again in games against Slavia Prague and Sunderland, but the Spaniard endured mixed fortunes over those two games.

 

Meanwhile, Madueke’s absence has not been so damaging to Arsenal thanks to Bukayo Saka’s presence, although the ex-Chelsea winger made an effervescent start to his Gunners career before entering the infirmary.

 

When could Martin Odegaard, Gabriel Martinelli, Kai Havertz return?

 

Martinelli, Odegaard and Havertz do not appear to be so close to comebacks, but the report adds that Arteta is still banking on the trio returning for the unrelenting festive fixture schedule.

 

The Gunners’ North London derby precedes a daunting Champions League barttle with Bayern Munich on November 26, as well other all-capital clashes with Chelsea on November 30 and Brentford on December 3.

 

Odegaard and Havertz (both knee) may still make their returns before the end of the month, while Martinelli’s recent muscular problem should not take too much longer to heal either.

 

Meanwhile, Arsenal are supposedly hoping to schedule a behind-closed-doors friendly game for Jesus during the international break, as the striker builds up towards a competitive return in either late December or early January.

 

Continue Reading

Featured

Liverpool injury update: Alexander Isak, Alisson Becker and Jeremie Frimpong latest news and return dates

Published

on

Reds are hopeful their main injury woes will soon be over

 

 

Jeremie Frimpong, Alexander Isak and Alisson Becker

 

London Standard

 

Liverpool’s woes on the pitch hit a new low on Sunday with a 3-0 defeat at Manchester City, but their injury troubles are easing.

 

Alexander Isak was back in the matchday squad at the Etihad Stadium, though did not get off the bench, while Alisson Becker and Jeremie Frimpong are not too far behind.

 

It is very welcome news for Arne Slot, who has seen the Reds’ Premier League title defence all but end ahead of the November international break.

 

Here’s all the latest Liverpool injury news and return dates…

Alexander Isak

 

Alexander Isak returned to the matchday squad on Sunday but did not come off the bench against Manchester City despite Liverpool needing a goal.

 

The striker has been struggling with a groin injury but only returned to training with his team-mates on Friday so is lacking match fitness.

 

Ahead the weekend, Slot said of Isak: “He will train with the team for the first time today after being three weeks out. I know I said three weeks ago his pre-season was ended, so now we have to see where he is.

If you are three weeks only with the rehab, that doesn’t bring him back to the levels he was three weeks ago, although our rehab team has done an incredible job. You cannot compare rehab with games of football or training with the team. As much as we try to replicate it, it’s simply not possible. So, again I have to say give him some time.”

 

Potential return date: Nottingham Forest (H) on Saturday, November 22, 2025

 

Alisson Becker

 

Alisson Becker is nearing a return after a number of weeks out with a thigh injury.

 

Giorgi Mamardashvili has impressed in patches while acting as understudy, notably saving a penalty from Erling Haaland on Sunday, but Alisson’s imminent return will be a big boost for the Reds.

 

Sanierungspflicht: Was für Immobilienbesitzer giltFür wen gilt die Sanierungspflicht und was bringt das neue Heizungsgesetz? Ein Überblick.Schwäbisch Hall

 

 

Arne Slot said on Friday: “Alisson for sure [will be back] after the international break … we expect this.”

 

Potential return date: Nottingham Forest (H) on Saturday, November 22, 2025

Sidelined: Jeremie Frimpong

 

Jeremie Frimpong

 

Jeremie Frimpong is also nearing a return, but is a little behind Alisson Becker on his road to recovery.

 

The defender last month against Frankfurt suffered his second hamstring injury of the season and was ruled out for six weeks.

 

Arne Slot, though, has suggested that Frimpong is slightly ahead of schedule and could even return before the end of November.

 

The Reds boss said: “I expect Jeremie back after the international break as well because we play from November to March. But I don’t expect Jeremie to be fully fit [to face Nottingham] Forest.”

 

Potential return date: West Ham (A) on Sunday, November 30, 2025

 

Giovanni Leoni

 

Leoni suffered an ACL injury on his Liverpool debut against Southampton back in September.

 

The 18-year-old impressed in his first minutes in red, but was stretchered off shortly after.

 

He later underwent surgery and is expected to spend a year on the sidelines.

 

“He’s not in a good place, of course,” Slot said of the Italian. “He tore his ACL which means that he will be out for around a year.”

 

Potential return date: Late 2026

 

alexander isak

 

Alisson Becker

 

Continue Reading

Trending

Copyright © 2017 Zox News Theme. Theme by MVP Themes, powered by WordPress.