30 Greatest Defenders In Premier League History (Ranked)

The Premier League has showcased some of the finest defensive talent in football history, often being the difference between victory and defeat. These individuals stand as impenetrable fortresses at the back, providing an unshakable line of defence.

 

From title-winning captains to the best full-backs in the history of the game – the English top flight has seen it all. The greatest manager in Premier League history – Sir Alex Ferguson – once said: “Attack wins you games, defence wins you titles.” It’s hard to argue with the Scottish legend, and there are many examples of teams that have relied on a strong defence to help them to success.

 

José Mourinho’s Chelsea team from the 2004/05 campaign remains the best in Premier League history to date as the Blues only conceded 15 goals on their way to breaking up the domination Manchester United and Arsenal held over the division to that point. Had it not been for that incredible back four – some of whom we will discuss later – this wouldn’t have been possible. A solid defensive structure is the most important thing for many top managers including Ferguson and Mourinho.

 

Just as important is having the players capable of carrying out the instructions of their manager to an elite level. Whether that be a centre-back that is asked to put his body on the line for the team, or a full-back that is tasked with getting forward and becoming an extra attacker. All defenders are important to a team and that is why GIVEMESPORT have decided to look at the 20 greatest Premier League defenders of all time, ranking them from worst to best.

 

Ranking factors

 

When compiling a list of the top 20 defenders in Premier League history, the main factors taken into consideration:

 

Longevity

 

Goals

 

Assists

 

Clean Sheets

 

Importance to their team

 

Trophies won

 

A player that spent a lot of years representing a top team is always going to be remembered favourably as it shows a lot of quality to retain a spot in the elite club’s team over a prolonged period of time. The majority of players to make the list have won at least one Premier League title, and this is something to take into account, although some defenders narrowly missed out on the big prize despite their defensive brilliance.

 

In terms of goals and assists, this is a metric that is slightly more important to a full-back as these players spend more time in the opposition’s half than central defenders. With that being said, some centre-backs had a knack for popping up with vital goals on several occasions. Without further ado, let’s see who makes the list.

 

30Pablo Zabaleta

 

Manchester City, West Ham United

 

Some defenders can get under their opponents’ skin, which gives their side the edge in battle. That was often the case for Pablo Zabaleta, whose former Manchester City teammate Micah Richards can even grow weary of.

 

This trait blended seamlessly with the hard work and consistency the Argentine right-back produced throughout his career, including at the Etihad, where he won two Premier League titles. His constant energy and tireless work ethic, bombing up and down the channel, made him a cult hero with the Cityzens and later at West Ham United.

 

Pablo Zabaleta’s Premier League Statistics

 

Appearances

 

Goals

 

Assists

 

Clean Sheets

 

302

 

9

 

21

 

86

 

29Lauren

 

Arsenal

 

Arsene Wenger’s Invincibles’ title feat is one of the most outstanding achievements in English football, and his defence was crucial. One of his most-used players during that Premier League campaign was Lauren, who was defensively sound and an excellent outlet on the overlap.

 

Lauren, who chose Highbury over the Bernabeu, was a reliable presence that Wenger could count on, including filling in for shifts in other positions. He possessed an excellent reading of the game and displayed vital experience for Portsmouth during a short spell at Fratton Park in the latter stages of his career.

 

Lauren’s Premier League Statistics

 

Appearances

 

Goals

 

Assists

 

Clean Sheets

 

184

 

6

 

8

 

63

 

28Leighton Baines

 

Wigan Athletic, Everton

 

Leighton Baines will go down as one of the finest English full-backs to never win a Premier League title or trophy during their professional career. The Everton hero was a set-piece master, boasting a lethal left foot that caused problems from corners, free kicks and the penalty spot.

 

GIVEMESPORT Key Statistic: Leighton Baines has the most career combined goals and assists of any defender in Premier League history (85).

 

There’s no telling how successful Baines would have been had he made the step up to one of the usual suspects battling it out for the title. David Moyes wanted to make him one of his first signings at Manchester United in 2012. He still cemented his legacy as one of the best defenders the top flight has seen, and unfortunately, never got to taste Champions League football.

 

Leighton Baines’ Premier League Statistics

 

Appearances

 

Goals

 

Assists

 

Clean Sheets

 

420

 

32

 

53

 

113

 

27Ruben Dias

 

Manchester City

 

There arguably hasn’t been a bigger impact made by a defender arriving in the Premier League from abroad than Ruben Dias’ in the 2020-21 season. He joined Manchester City and claimed the top-flight’s Player of the Season award for his stellar debut campaign.

 

The Portuguese centre-back has since become a leader at the Etihad, part of the side that claimed the continental treble in 2022-23. He’s occasionally worn the captain’s armband for the Cityzens and has been the perfect heir to club legend Vincent Kompany.

 

Ruben Dias’ Premier League Statistics

 

Appearances

 

Goals

 

Assists

 

Clean Sheets

 

146

 

3

 

4

 

54

 

26Sami Hyypia

 

Liverpool

 

One of the biggest bargain buys in Premier League history was Sami Hyypia, who quickly became a fan favourite at Anfield. The colossal six-foot-four-inch Finnish centre-back joined the Reds for a mere £2.6m in 1999 and was worth every penny.

 

Hyypia may not have got his hands on the Premier League title, but he was a rock at the back for Liverpool. He wasn’t afraid to put his body on the line and displayed bravery that even earned the respect of Duncan Ferguson. His most significant achievement was winning the Champions League in 2005.

 

Sami Hyypia’s Premier League Statistics

 

Appearances

 

Goals

 

Assists

 

Clean Sheets

 

318

 

22

 

8

 

125

 

25Andy Robertson

 

Hull City, Liverpool

 

While the right side of the Liverpool defence was often the one that was spotlighted for better or worse, Andy Robertson on the left was arguably more consistent and just as important as the Reds went from obscurity to Premier League champions.

 

Having impressed for minnows Hull City in his first Premier League campaign, the Scot moved to Liverpool and became a key part of Jurgen Klopp’s side. While not as accomplished with the ball at his feet as his counterpart on the opposite flank, Robertson still provided plenty of assists and was more stable defensively. It’s this combination that makes him one of the best full-backs in Premier League history.

 

Andy Robertson’s Premier League Statistics

 

Appearances

 

Goals

 

Assists

 

Clean Sheets

 

309

 

11

 

60

 

84

 

The Greatest Scottish 11 in Premier League History

 

24Martin Keown

 

Arsenal, Aston Villa, Everton

 

You wouldn’t know it looking at his soft-spoken punditry, but Martin Keown was as nasty as they come. Having started at Arsenal, the centre-half moved to Aston Villa and Everton before returning to Highbury, where he made himself a key part of George Graham and Arsene Wenger’s squad.

 

Keown was a part of the Gunners’ double winners in 1998 and a part of the Invincibles too, though in a much more rotational capacity. The image of him squaring off with Ruud van Nistelrooy after the Dutchman’s penalty smashed against the crossbar is all the more reason for him to be included — for that iconic moment alone.

 

Martin Keown’s Premier League Statistics

 

Appearances

 

Clean Sheets

 

Games Won

 

Games Lost

 

323

 

108

 

161

 

68

 

23John Stones

 

Everton, Manchester City

 

Injuries perhaps stopped John Stones from reaching the heights of other English greats like John Terry and Rio Ferdinand, but what he has achieved as part of an incredible Manchester City side makes him a viable candidate for the top 25. Having cut his teeth at Everton prior to the move to the Etihad, Stones had a topsy-turvy time under Pep Guardiola — sometimes being favoured, other times not.

 

However, as he developed under the Catalonian coach, he became more assured and more present, establishing himself as a crucial part of the City team. His goal-line clearance against Liverpool in 2019 will be watched over and over and was ultimately the difference between City and Liverpool in that season’s race to the top.

 

John Stones’ Premier League Statistics

 

Appearances

 

Clean Sheets

 

Games Won

 

Games Lost

 

250

 

75

 

156

 

50

 

22Trent Alexander-Arnold

 

Liverpool

 

Undoubtedly a revolutionary name in the Premier League era, the reason why Trent Alexander-Arnold doesn’t break the top 20 is that, despite being a defender, it was that part of his game that was notably weakest. Going forward, the flying full-back was incredible. His vision and crossing ability were unlike anything else seen.

 

A two-time Premier League winner, his attacking play ensures that he still deserves to be considered in the same light as other greats, as his influence on Liverpool’s resurgence cannot be understated. Reds fans often defended the Englishman’s defensive vulnerabilities, but most won’t be following his controversial move to Real Madrid in 2025.

 

Trent Alexander-Arnold’s Premier League Statistics

 

Appearances

 

Goals

 

Assists

 

Clean Sheets

 

259

 

18

 

64

 

72

 

21Paul McGrath

 

Manchester United, Aston Villa, Derby County

 

You can’t have a list of the best defenders the Premier League has ever seen without the man who won the PFA Player of the Year award in the first season after the rebrand of the English top flight. That’s right, the recipient of the 1992/93 trophy was none other than Aston Villa’s Paul McGrath.

 

The Irish defender had previously had a stint at Manchester United, and left the club just a few years before they would embark on their dominant run to the top of English football. However, McGrath would still carve out his own legacy at Villa Park, before finishing his top-flight career at Derby County.

 

Paul McGrath’s Premier League Statistics

 

Appearances

 

Clean Sheets

 

Games Won

 

Games Lost

 

166

 

40

 

63

 

55